The way I read it, this seems to be a review of a no-show, which I thought was not allowed. The reviewer claims to have hired Noah before, but he is a first-time reviewer, so it can't be claimed that this is an addendum to a review of a previous meeting, since there is no previous review. What is the story?
(I am aware that Noah has a questionable reputation on this board already.)
(I am aware that Noah has a questionable reputation on this board already.)